Showing posts with label Bulletin 2008-2009. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bulletin 2008-2009. Show all posts

November 25, 2009

Society of Comparative Literature Bulletin 2008-2009


Revenge - Beyond the Slings and Arrows

Contents

Preface: The Turbulent Voyages of Vengeance / Dr. Esther M. K. Cheung

沒有人問正義和公理的問題——論李維怡小說集《行路難》裡公義倫理的探詢 / 盧勁馳

復仇之花 / 潘國靈

Inauthenticity of Revenge in Hamlet and Chronicle of a Death Foretold / Dr. Paul Kong

沒復仇電影的仇 / 皮亞

《復仇》與復仇 / Winnie Yee

Trauma Revisited / Eliza Man-yee Lau

復仇無界——香港大學學生會文學院學生會比較文學學會 2009 年比較文學節專題展覽

Film Reviews
     《公主復仇記》——公主復仇力量大?/ 馮淑儀
     Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street / Gavin Tse

Acknowledgement

Preface: The Turbulent Voyages of Vengeance / Dr. Esther M. K. Cheung

When you leaf through the following pages of this year’s Comparative Literature Bulletin, you will see how the spirit of revenge has gone through many forms of metamorphosis. From the ancient Hellenic view of divine retribution to contemporary popular modes of vengeance, stories of revenge engage their readers/viewers as much as they consume their creators. Acts of revenge probably embody the strongest emotions ever known to humans; desires of revenge produce a complex matrix of affects where envy, jealousy, indignation, hatred, and love are intertwined with each other.

沒有人問正義和公理的問題──論李維怡小說集《行路難》裡公義倫理的探詢 / 盧勁馳

引言
要談仇恨和政治的關係,國外都有很多關於忌恨政治 (politic of resentment) 的討論,主要指出了社會上的族群衝突,都建立在一種召喚種族認同的情感結構裡,喜歡想象自己是受害者,他人為加害者,藉此建立穩固的族群身份。如台灣學者趙剛有一書名為 《告別妒恨》,正好分析出這種邏輯如何支配著台灣的省籍對立問題,如何令民主社會的發展停滯不前。妒恨政治的最大問題,在於令反抗政治落入了一種復仇的欲望結構之中,沒有好好處理歷史的創口,往往藉著受害者的名義,向其他的社群施以更大的暴力。

每次讀到這種對於復仇政治的分析,都感到一份陌生感,香港的政治不是沒有暴力,只是暴力很少來自受害社群的反撲,在媒體上的少數族裔、新來港人士、性工作者、邊緣少年或受重建影響的街坊,往往只是一面倒地受到各種社會政策文化機制的傷害,在未及把受害提升為反抗政治的資源以前,早就給穩定壓到一切的主流意見河蟹過去。於是,復仇只是一點小眉小眼的個體情感,或許只有一點點的妒恨,甚至妒恨都不是。

復仇之花 / 潘國靈

開筆寫這篇文章前,本想看看杜琪峰最新作品《復仇》,不料上映不久便淡出各大院線。但想想,如果不那麼「名正言順」的話,近作《竊聽風雲》(古天樂最後變身半人半機械般駕車衝過斷橋與王敏德同歸於盡)、《希魔撞正殺人狂》等,也包含「復仇」元素。沒正式統計,主觀印象,近年復仇主題在世界影壇也頗領風騷。

近年的復仇電影
韓國朴贊郁的「復仇三部曲」(《復仇》、《原罪犯》、《親切的金子》)揚名海外,在影像中燃起一片極盡暴烈的復仇火海。電影怪傑昆倫.塔倫天奴的「新娘復仇記」《標殺令》、《標殺令2》拍出奇詭暴力美學,新作《希魔撞正殺人狂》題材風格有別,但貫徹其中的仍有「復仇」母題,逃過納粹追殺的少女,後經營戲院,一把大火把看宣傳片首映的德軍燒清光與菲林同葬。

Inauthenticity of Revenge in Hamlet and Chronicle of a Death Foretold / Dr. Paul Kong

Revenge, etymologically, is from the Old French word vengier, meaning to claim, set free or punish, and the prefix ‘re’ stresses the direction – it’s a reaction targeting ‘back’ to the causer. In other words, ‘revenge’ means the setting free of a desire to inflict punishment in return (usually for injury or insult).

This desire for revenge can easily be noticed in Shakespeare’s Hamlet and García Márquez’s Chronicle of a Death Foretold. The unjust act, in the former is the murder of Old Hamlet by his brother Claudius, and in the latter is the deflowering of Angela Vicario, which is discovered on the night of her wedding. Hamlet reacts to this by killing Claudius and in a like manner, Angela’s twin brothers, Pedro and Pablo respond to the injury inflicted upon their sister by killing Santiago Nasar, a person named by her when she is pressed as to who the ‘real’ perpetrator is. The irrationality of Pedro and Pablo’s revenge is conspicuous while the one of Hamlet is rather subtle (and this begs a thorough scrutiny in the future). But one commonality regarding the revenge in these two texts is that the act of revenge is carried out on behalf of the victim. This means in these two texts, the avenger acts in the name of, or as the agent of the victim, rather than being the victim himself or herself. This is a reaction by means of substitution – the avenger substituting the victim in inflicting the punishment upon the avenged. In other words, this is a revenge done in the form of substitution for an ‘other’. This other, on one level, is the victim deemed dear and valuable to the avenger. But on a collective and metaphorical level, this sense of the ‘other’ can refer to what Heidegger calls ‘they-hood’, which is present in the ‘they-self’ in each of us.

沒復仇電影的仇 / 皮亞

杜琪峰的電影《復仇》,做了香港、澳門、法國三地文化的紅娘,導演手法保持現代武俠風格,場景設置也富獨特的異國風情,不過較為令人失望的,是沒有拍出三地文化的差異。法籍男主角Johnny Hallyday 年輕時也是殺手,他堅信在酒店偶然碰上的「陌生人」,由黃秋生率領的三人殺手組織,會為他執行殺人任務;同一時間黃秋生等人都「法國佬」的底細也從無過問,難道真是四海之內皆兄弟,有錢使得鬼推磨?當然我們未當過殺手,不知「行內人」如何交易,特別是當黃秋生等殺手,得知最後要殺的主腦,原來就是自己經常合作的黑幫老闆任達華的時候,仍然捨命為陌生的法國佬服務,與黑幫老闆,即是與「自己人」火拼,情操上也就超越了金錢交易的關係(片中也沒有特別強調黃秋生等人被一筆非常巨大的獎金吸引),換句話說,黃秋生等人在執行任務的過程中,與法國佬發生了超越金錢交易的友誼關係,即時武俠片中惺惺相惜的男性情義。更有理由相信,黃秋生等殺手是同情Johnny Hallyday 女兒一家被殺,連孩子也不放過。但吊詭的是,任達華也透露下令殺手追殺的,只是與己有恩怨的男人和女人而己(即Johnny Hallyday 的女兒和丈夫),但執行任務的殺手因為不慎被躲藏的孩子目睹相貌,便毫不猶疑殺人滅口。

《復仇》與復仇 / Winnie Yee

復仇的故事從來不缺,不論中外故事或電影橋段,比比皆是。需要解釋的是,原因何在?為什麼需要復仇?是因為社會上的不公義總不能被解決,又或是人心險惡,世途多難,生存與仇恨本是互為而生?

復仇往往是倖存者的生命動力,也是揭示正邪對立的手段。因此復仇故事往往帶有兩個重要的任命:取回公義、懲罰壞人(Simkin, 26)。一般的故事更是透過復仇的過程,進而探究復仇者內心的狀態和其意識的流動。莎士比亞(WilliamShakespeare)的哈雷姆特《Hamlet 》(1601)便是當中的最佳代表。有了復仇的使命,配上復仇過程中的掙扎,讀者或觀眾便有了思考的空間及時間,逐步代入復仇者的思想歷程,理解並開始認同復仇的迫不得已或其合理性。當然,復仇的使命往往帶出更迫切的思考據點:命運之不可改變,復仇本是不能擺脫的宿命。

Trauma Revisited / Eliza Man-yee Lau

The vision of a world in peace is not only possible, but that it begins here, begins now, with each one of us, looking deeply within, and honoring our limitless potential.
──Sogyal Rinpoche, the author of The Tibetan Book of Living and Dying
A wound can be either physical or psychological. And as far as healing is concerned, psychological wounds are far more complex and difficult to deal with. Medical science has enabled man to assess the extent of damage to the body and to prescribe appropriate measures of cure accurately and in sophisticated ways. However, with regard to psychological traumas, scientists and psychiatric practitioners are still struggling with how such traumas could be properly understood, let alone prescribing appropriate treatment measures or remedy. In the book Trauma: Explorations in Memory, Cathy Caruth wrote:

復仇無界——2009 年比較文學節專題展覽

比較文學節,是比較文學學會一年一度的活動,目的為推廣比較文學,加深同學對此學科的認識。是年,本學會以「復仇」作比較文學節的主題,探索「復仇」於不同文本及文化中呈現之變化。至於此文章是本學會在比較文學節中的專題展覽。

復仇,表面看來是一個簡單的詞語,代表著以牙還牙,血債血償。而對復仇的情節,我們更見怪不怪。但大家有否留意復仇背後的各項因素,以及復仇是否合理?復仇這個題材非常普及,不論是莎翁的《王子復仇記》,還是現代的《公主復仇記》或其他電影小說,也會與復仇有關,從而燃起了本學會對此題目的興趣。本年度比較文學節會帶大家進入復仇的世界,拆解箇中乾坤,突破界限。以下我們會從電影、小說等不同文本分析復仇,以及討論男女復仇是否有別。

《原罪犯》:復仇的出路
《原罪犯》中吳大秀無故遭禁錮十五年,皆因學生時代撞破李宇珍姊弟亂倫一幕而間接害死其姊。他重見天日後誓言手刃仇人,結果自投禁錮者另一個復仇陷阱—他被催眠與自己的女兒美道相愛並交合,最後割舌謝罪,再次催眠自己以忘記二人的父女關係。套用李字珍的一句話:「報仇過,又如何?」復仇本身就是一種催眠,是一場復仇者與受害者的困獸鬥,醒悟後,彼此赫見同是一無所有的受害者。復仇的至高境界是以愛為手段的精神虐待,更要禍及下一代,然而仇恨既源於愛,理應止於愛。《原罪犯》淒美的結局,寓意「忘記」或是復仇的最終出路。

《公主復仇記》——公主復仇力量大? / 馮淑儀


《公主復仇記》 (Beyond Our Ken, 2004)
導演:彭浩翔   編劇:彭浩翔
演員:鍾欣桐   陶紅   吳彥祖

在《大丈夫》中,毛舜筠體面讓丈夫避過捉姦在床的尷尬,《出埃及記》女性則以上帝的姿態殺男人,彭浩翔看似賦予電影女性無限權力,足以與男人抗衡之餘,更可成為愛情角力的主導。說實話,一切只是彭導描述兩性爭權的一貫風格,兜兜轉轉,女性始終苦無權力,只有短暫的心靈慰藉,《公主復仇記》正是最佳體證。

Film Review: Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street / Gavin Tse


Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007)
Directed by Tim Burton
Written by Stephen Sondheim, Hugh Wheeler, Christopher Bond, John Logan
Starring: Johnny Depp, Helena Bonham Carter, Alan Rickman, Timothy Spall, Sacha Baron Cohen, Jamie Campbell Bower, Laura Michelle Kelly, Jayne Wisener, Ed Sanders
“There was a barber and his wife, and she was beautiful…”
The story of Sweeney Todd was a story of lust, betrayal and revenge. Sweeney Todd’s mind was bent on revenge after his wife and daughter had been coveted by a corrupt judge, and himself unjustly hurled into prison. The plot was strikingly similar to Alexandre Dumas’s epic novel The Count of Monte Cristo, hence articulating certain espousals of the traditional revenge plot. Yet while there were strong intertextual echoes to Dumas’s novel, Tim Burton’s stylistic play with colours created a gruesome, bleak, gothic atmosphere within the film. The dark, moody aura signified London as a cannibalistic society, “a hole in the world like a great black pit and the vermin of the world inhabit it”. The setting predicated the mode of revenge in the film: the inevitable brutality and ferociousness.

Bulletin 2008-2009: Acknowledgement

Dr. Esther M. K. Cheung
盧勁馳
潘國靈
Dr. Paul Kong
皮亞
Winnie Yee
Eliza Man-yee Lau
馮淑儀
Gavin Tse

Society of Comparative Literature, A.A.H.K.U.S.U., Session 2008-2009
Executive Committee

Chairperson: Carmen Ka-man Mak
Internal Vice-Chairperson: Veronica Wing-wing Chu
External Vice-Chairperson: Gareth Sze-lok Lee
General Secretary & Social Secretary: April Ka-yeng Fung
Financial Secretary & Sports Captain: Winter Yu-hin Cheung
Academic Secretary: Gavin Wing-hin Tse
Publication Secretary: Dora Wing-sum Yeung
Welfare Secretary" Vivian Wai-man Au

Date of publication: October 2009
Editor: Yeung Wing Sum, Dora